FluentSMTP vs Paymattic

Our pick is the FluentSMTP (9.0/10 vs 7.8). Below: scores, prices at every store, specs, and what we like and don’t about each. Prices are the latest we found and can change.

Comparison of 2 products
Feature FluentSMTP logo WordPress Plugins FluentSMTP (free WordPress email delivery) Top score Lowest price Paymattic logo WordPress Plugins Paymattic (WordPress payments and donations) Lowest price
Our score9.0 Excellent7.8 Good
Reader rating 0.0 (0) 0.0 (0)
Best price Free at WordPress.org
View deal
Free at WordPress.org
View deal
Brand / developerWPManageNinjaWPManageNinja
Pricing modelFreeFree plan + paid upgrades
PlatformsWordPressWordPress
Prices by store
Official site — $119.00/yr
WordPress.org Free Free
Specifications
Latest version2.4.5 (4 Nov 2026)4.6.28 (9 Oct 2026)
Active installations700,000+3,000+
WordPress.org rating4.8 / 5 (414 ratings)4.8 / 5
RequiresWordPress 6.5+, PHP 7.4+WordPress 5.3+, PHP 7.4+
Email servicesAmazon SES, Gmail, Microsoft 365, SendGrid, Mailgun, Postmark, Brevo, any SMTP and more—
PriceFree, no Pro version—
Pro (regular)—$119/yr 1 site · $239/yr 20 sites · $359/yr unlimited
Lifetime—From $349 (1 site)
Pros & cons
What we like
  • 100% free, with no Pro version or upsells
  • Works with Amazon SES, Gmail, Microsoft 365, SendGrid, Mailgun, Postmark, Brevo and more
  • Fallback connection and routing by sender address
  • Email logs, resend, health checks and failure alerts
  • Free Stripe payments and donations with ready-made templates
  • Donation progress bar, PDF invoices and multi-step forms
  • Free FluentCRM, Mailchimp, Slack and Zapier integrations
  • Spam protection with reCAPTCHA, Turnstile and honeypot
Could be better
  • You still need an account with an email sending service
  • Setting up provider DNS records (SPF, DKIM) takes some care
  • Logs are stored in your database and need pruning on busy sites
  • Subscriptions and recurring donations need Pro
  • PayPal, Square, Mollie and most gateways are Pro
  • Smaller user base (3,000+ installations)
VerdictFree, with no Pro upsell, and it fixes one of WordPress’s most common problems. Worth installing on almost any site. Full review A tidy way to take payments and donations without a full shop. Recurring payments and most gateways need Pro. Full review

Store links are affiliate links: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How we earn money.